Cell Phone Search Checklist for School Administrators

default_cyberbullying

Justin and I have been trying to figure out a way to help inform school administrators as to when they can go ahead and search the contents of student cell phones. Week after week after week, this is one of the primary questions we receive from them. We want to help guide them in a meaningful way without getting enmeshed in a large number of due process and consent issues. As such, I’d like to present this checklist as a flowchart of sorts to assist with the decision-making process whenever student cell phones are displayed and used in school environments where that display and use is prohibited. To note, this is a work-in-progress, and we would love to dialogue with you more about what is missing. As always, please consult your school district attorney before engaging in an action where you are unsure of the legal implications.

 

Cell Phone Search Checklist for School Administrators

 

Has the student consented to the search?

 

Yes or No (circle one)

 

If student will not consent, has the student’s parent consented?

 

Yes or No (circle one)

 

If no consent from student or parent, is it an emergency (an actual or imminent threat to public health or safety, which may result in loss of life, injury or property damage)?

 

Yes or No (circle one)

 

If no consent from student or parent, and no emergency is indicated, is it reasonable for you to believe a school policy violation has occurred and evidence that proves that violation is possibly on the device? Would you be able to articulate the reasoning before a court of law if necessary?

 

Yes or No (circle one)

 

Do you understand the scope of your cell phone search can go no further than the data locations (such as call logs, text records, photos) that specifically relate to the suspected policy violation?

 

Yes or No (circle one)

 

Have you spoken to other School District officials AND Legal Counsel to determine if it is to discuss the proposed search and surrounding
circumstances and ensure their appropriateness?

 

Yes or No (circle one)

 

Are you sure that this is not a law enforcement matter that then would require probable cause for a law enforcement officer to search the phone?

 

Yes or No (circle one)

 

Do you have an agreement with local law enforcement (including a stationed school resource officer at your school), that outlines a specific process, supported by state and federal search and seizure law, for conducting cell phone searches by police officers?

 

AT TIME OF INCIDENT:

 

Describe the circumstances under which the student’s cell phone was seized:

 

Describe the circumstances that you think give rise to a reasonable suspicion that the cell phone was used in violation of the law or a district policy:

 

—–

 

What do you, our readers, think – based on your own experiences? Our ultimate goal with this is to more concretly ensure that the school administration has thought things through, and have received informed input from legal counsel and law enforcement as needed.

1 Comment

  1. I keep reading these posts about teachers or administration personal searching the contents of a student's phone and I have to wonder, would you attempt the same search of a teachers cell phone? Or of a college student? Or any other adult? Teachers definitely need to be able to maintain order in their classrooms, but if the teachers and administrative personal are not going to freely hand over their cell phones to any person who asks for said person to search and investigate, why should a student?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *